Catcher
Ted Simmons - Reds (Cardinals)
First Base
Mark McGwire - A's (Oakland A's)
Second Base
Joe Morgan - Colts (Colt .45s)
Third Base
Nolan Arenado - Nuts (Rockies)
Shortstop
Troy Tulowitzki - Nuts (Rockies)
Outfield
Rickey Henderson - A's (Oakland A's)
Dwayne Murphy - A's (Oakland A's)
Jose Canseco - A's (Oakland A's)
Designated Hitter
Reggie Jackson - Reds (Kansas City A's)
Starting Pitchers
John Denny - Reds (Cardinals)
Kevin Tapani - A's (Oakland A's)
Bob Forsch - Reds (Cardinals)
Matt Keough - A's (Oakland A's)
Rick Honeycutt - A's (Oakland A's)
Relief Pitchers
Rollie Fingers - Reds (Kansas City A's)
Al Hrabosky - Reds (Cardinals)
Pedro Borbon - Reds (Cardinals)
Jay Howell - A's (Oakland A's)
Tom Burgmeier - Colts (Colt .45s)
Bench
Mickey Tettleton - A's (Oakland A's)
Jason Giambi - A's (Oakland A's)
Tony Batista - A's (Oakland A's)
Miguel Tejada - A's (Oakland A's)
Joe Rudi
Charlie Blackmon - Nuts (Rockies)
Manager
Sparky Anderson - Reds (Cardinals)
Note: The cards are all in my collection and the pics are from TCDB (per usual).